GET FIT TECH
Sign up for the FREE digital edition of Fit Tech magazine and also get the Fit Tech ezine and breaking news email alerts.
Not right now, thanksclose this window I've already subscribed!
Technogym | Fit Tech promotion
Technogym | Fit Tech promotion
Technogym | Fit Tech promotion
FIT TECH News

F45 loses lawsuit against Body Fit Training, with two software patents being invalidated

By
Body Fit Training has successfully defeated a court action brought by F45 in defence of two software patents relating to the fundamentals of its business operations
The action was heard by Justice Nicholas in the Australian Federal Court
Two F45 patents were deemed invalid by the judge and costs awarded to Body Fit Training
The two companies are also locked in a similar legal battle in the US
The Federal Court has determined that both of F45’s patents are invalid and that, even if they had been valid, BFT did not infringe them, Cameron Falloon, founder and joint CEO, Body Fit Training
The Federal Court has determined that both of F45’s patents are invalid and that, even if they had been valid, BFT did not infringe them
– Cameron Falloon, founder and joint CEO, Body Fit Training

Body Fit Training (BFT), the Australian fitness franchise, has successfully defended a court action brought by F45 in the Australian Federal Court.

The lawsuit between the two Australian companies is part of an ongoing global dispute over business strategies and the use of technology.

It began in late 2019, when F45 filed a lawsuit in the Australian Federal Court against BFT over an alleged patent infringement, aiming to protect the way it manages its franchises through a central computer system.

F45 asserted that Body Fit had infringed its intellectual property rights in relation to the proprietory software it uses to manage its locations, however, Justice Nicholas ruled that F45 had no proprietary rights, while his ruling also stated that two F45 patents were invalid and should be revoked. He awarded costs against F45.

Joint CEOs of BFT, Cameron Falloon and Richard Burnet, said: ”The Federal Court has determined that both of F45’s innovation patents are invalid and that – even if those patents had been valid – BFT did not infringe them in any event."

The two companies are also locked in a legal battle in the US and although the result in the Australian courts will not decide the US case, it may influence the outcome.

BFT’s star is on the rise, with the company having sold the US and Canadian rights to its franchise business to Xponential Fitness in October 2021 for US$44m (AUS$66), plus additional payments based on growth, while retaining the master franchise rights for Australia, New Zealand and Singapore for itself.

At the time, industry commentators expressed the view that Xpontential would have been unlikely to invest if it felt F45’s court action had a chance of success.

The F45 patents

F45’s two patents were registered under different numbers, however, they were both recorded as being for “The remote configuration and operation of fitness studios from a central server.”

In his summing up, Justice Nicholas said: ”The invention is carried out using generic computing technology facilitating communications between a server with access to a database of files and one or more studio computers, which in turn communicate with displays located at the various exercise stations.

"The substance of the invention resides not in the actual physical arrangement of the exercise stations, but in the computer-implemented scheme that enables those physical arrangements to be made.

"It is the kind of scheme that has historically never been regarded as patentable subject matter,” he said. “The scheme is not made patentable merely because it is implemented using generic computing technology."

More fit tech news
The ICO has ruled that eight leisure operators have been unlawfully processing the biometric data of their employees to be ...
news • 23 Feb 2024
More consumers are realising meditation is beneficial, but many give up because it’s difficult to master the mind. The Muse ...
news • 21 Feb 2024
Newcomer to the market, Lunar Health Clubs, is gearing up to open its first high-end club this April, in Marlow ...
news • 19 Feb 2024
University of Washington researchers have created a wireless wearable in the form of a thermal earring that continuously monitors a ...
news • 16 Feb 2024
Zumba, and virtual reality workout platform, FitXR, have joined forces to offer mixed-reality versions of Zumba's dance routines. The partnership ...
news • 13 Feb 2024
Triathlon legends, Alistair and Jonny Brownlee, have launched a free conversational AI tool to share their vast training knowledge with ...
news • 07 Feb 2024
Self Esteem Brands (SEB), owner of Anytime Fitness, has released year-end results which show year-on-year revenues up by 12.3 per ...
More HCM news
According to McKinsey’s latest report, The trends defining the US$1.8 trillion global wellness market in 2024, the market for wellness ...
news • 24 Jan 2024
One of the most famous bodybuilders of all time – turned Hollywood actor – turned Californian governor – Arnold Schwarzenegger, ...
news • 23 Jan 2024
Egym has signalled its intention to become a major global player in the health club equipment space, signing up former ...
news • 19 Jan 2024
With pressure on medical services at an all time high, the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change is calling for ...
news • 17 Jan 2024
Sennheiser has teamed up with Polar Electro for the launch of its Momentum Sport earbuds which deliver Polar’s bio-sensing capabilities ...
news • 09 Jan 2024
The fitness industry is gearing up to engage with the medical profession according to the results of the American College ...
news • 05 Jan 2024
TikTok, has launched into the fitness market with a new hub called #TikTokFitness and a supporting consumer marketing push. The ...
news • 05 Jan 2024
Les Mills has released Les Mills XR Dance for the Meta Quest 3 headset. The release is the company's second ...
news • 20 Dec 2023
Equinox has appointed a Health Advisory Board of medical experts and academics to 'define new frontiers in the science of ...
news • 15 Dec 2023
Horizon Leisure is upgrading and investing in its new shopping-centre health hub – The Wellbeing Hub in Havant, UK – ...
news • 15 Dec 2023
Google has just released Gemini, a new multimodal AI which is being billed as a "ChatGPT Killer". Unlike ChatGPT, it ...
news • 06 Dec 2023
Survivalist, Bear Grylls has partnered with four mental health heavyweights and former TV producer, Neil Smith, to create an app ...
news • 06 Dec 2023
Sport Alliance has named Erwin Korst vice president sales international. The appointment comes as the company announces US$100m of new ...
news • 04 Dec 2023
Training provider, The Fitness Group, has teamed up with personal training app, My PT Hub, to make it easier for ...
news • 19 Nov 2023
The Maybourne Hotel Group – manager of iconic global hotels including Claridges, The Berkeley and The Connaught – has partnered ...
news • 17 Nov 2023
Timbaland, Platinum Grammy Award-winning producer, who's worked with artists such as Jay-Z, Missy Elliott, Madonna, Rihanna, Justin Timberlake and Drake ...
news • 15 Nov 2023
Connected fitness equipment supplier, Echelon Fitness, has signed a multi-year deal with Run Disney, the road race division of Disney ...
news • 14 Nov 2023
The first ever Siro hotel, marketed as the "ultimate fitness and recovery hotel", is now accepting reservations. Set to open ...
news • 09 Nov 2023
The rapid advance of technology in all areas of life is putting societies in flux, creating uncertainty and forcing people ...
news • 05 Nov 2023
Apple has teamed up with Anytime Fitness to offer levels of reciprocal access between Apple Fitness+ and Anytime Fitness health ...
news • 02 Nov 2023
Tech giant, Huawei, has launched a new Health Lab, where it will conduct research on how it can "provide better ...
news • 01 Nov 2023
Les Mills is jumping into Mixed Reality with the launch of the Bodycombat XR workout, designed by programme directors, Rachael ...
news • 16 Oct 2023
A new startup is looking to carve out a market for itself by helping those working in sports and physical ...
news • 12 Oct 2023
Interactive Strength, maker of fitness screen FORME, has revealed plans to acquire vertical climber brand CLMBR for an undisclosed sum. ...
news • 12 Oct 2023
More fit tech news
Art of Cryo is a new division of a renowned family business with 30 years’ ...
Power Plate is owned, manufactured and distributed by Northbrook, Ill.- based Performance Health Systems LLC, ...
Salt therapy products
Cryotherapy
Digital
Lockers
Flooring
20-22 Mar 2024
The Salil Hotel Riverside, Bangkok, Bangkok, Thailand
Art of Cryo is a new division of a renowned family business with 30 years’ ...
Power Plate is owned, manufactured and distributed by Northbrook, Ill.- based Performance Health Systems LLC, ...
Get Fit Tech
Sign up for the free Fit Tech ezine and breaking news alerts
Sign up
Salt therapy products
Cryotherapy
Digital
Lockers
Flooring
20-22 Mar 2024
The Salil Hotel Riverside, Bangkok, Bangkok, Thailand

features

Innovation

Bold move

We ended up raising US$7m in venture capital from incredible investors, including Andreessen Horowitz, Khosla Ventures, Primetime Partners, and GingerBread Capital
Fit Tech people

Hannes Sjöblad

MD, DSruptive
We want to give our users an implantable tool that allows them to collect their health data at any time and in any setting
Fit Tech people

Ali Jawad

Paralympic powerlifter and founder, Accessercise
Users can easily identify which facilities in the UK are accessible to the disabled community
Editor's letter

Into the fitaverse

Fitness is already among the top three markets in the metaverse, with new technology and partnerships driving real growth and consumer engagement that looks likely to spill over into health clubs, gyms and studios
Opinion

Building on the blockchain

For small sports teams looking to compete with giants, blockchain can be a secret weapon explains Lars Rensing, CEO of Protokol
App analysis

Check your form

Sency’s motion analysis technology is allowing users to check their technique as they exercise. Co-founder and CEO Gal Rotman explains how
Fit Tech people

Jamie Buck

Co-founder, Active in Time
We created a solution called AiT Voice, which turns digital data into a spoken audio timetable that connects to phone systems
Profile

New reality

Sam Cole, CEO of FitXR, talks to Fit Tech about taking digital workouts to the next level, with an immersive, virtual reality fitness club
Profile

Sohail Rashid

My vision was to create a platform that could improve the sport for lifters at all levels and attract more people, similar to how Strava, Peloton and Zwift have in other sports
Ageing

Reverse Ageing

Many apps help people track their health, but Humanity founders Peter Ward and Michael Geer have put the focus on ageing, to help users to see the direct repercussions of their habits. They talk to Steph Eaves
Profile

Fahad Alhagbani: reinventing fitness

Let’s live in the future to improve today
App analysis

Going hybrid

Workout Anytime created its app in partnership with Virtuagym. Workout Anytime’s Greg Maurer and Virtuagym’s Hugo Braam explain the process behind its creation
More features
FIT TECH News

F45 loses lawsuit against Body Fit Training, with two software patents being invalidated

By
Body Fit Training has successfully defeated a court action brought by F45 in defence of two software patents relating to the fundamentals of its business operations
The action was heard by Justice Nicholas in the Australian Federal Court
Two F45 patents were deemed invalid by the judge and costs awarded to Body Fit Training
The two companies are also locked in a similar legal battle in the US
The Federal Court has determined that both of F45’s patents are invalid and that, even if they had been valid, BFT did not infringe them, Cameron Falloon, founder and joint CEO, Body Fit Training
The Federal Court has determined that both of F45’s patents are invalid and that, even if they had been valid, BFT did not infringe them
– Cameron Falloon, founder and joint CEO, Body Fit Training

Body Fit Training (BFT), the Australian fitness franchise, has successfully defended a court action brought by F45 in the Australian Federal Court.

The lawsuit between the two Australian companies is part of an ongoing global dispute over business strategies and the use of technology.

It began in late 2019, when F45 filed a lawsuit in the Australian Federal Court against BFT over an alleged patent infringement, aiming to protect the way it manages its franchises through a central computer system.

F45 asserted that Body Fit had infringed its intellectual property rights in relation to the proprietory software it uses to manage its locations, however, Justice Nicholas ruled that F45 had no proprietary rights, while his ruling also stated that two F45 patents were invalid and should be revoked. He awarded costs against F45.

Joint CEOs of BFT, Cameron Falloon and Richard Burnet, said: ”The Federal Court has determined that both of F45’s innovation patents are invalid and that – even if those patents had been valid – BFT did not infringe them in any event."

The two companies are also locked in a legal battle in the US and although the result in the Australian courts will not decide the US case, it may influence the outcome.

BFT’s star is on the rise, with the company having sold the US and Canadian rights to its franchise business to Xponential Fitness in October 2021 for US$44m (AUS$66), plus additional payments based on growth, while retaining the master franchise rights for Australia, New Zealand and Singapore for itself.

At the time, industry commentators expressed the view that Xpontential would have been unlikely to invest if it felt F45’s court action had a chance of success.

The F45 patents

F45’s two patents were registered under different numbers, however, they were both recorded as being for “The remote configuration and operation of fitness studios from a central server.”

In his summing up, Justice Nicholas said: ”The invention is carried out using generic computing technology facilitating communications between a server with access to a database of files and one or more studio computers, which in turn communicate with displays located at the various exercise stations.

"The substance of the invention resides not in the actual physical arrangement of the exercise stations, but in the computer-implemented scheme that enables those physical arrangements to be made.

"It is the kind of scheme that has historically never been regarded as patentable subject matter,” he said. “The scheme is not made patentable merely because it is implemented using generic computing technology."

More fit tech news
The ICO has ruled that eight leisure operators have been unlawfully processing the biometric data of their employees to be ...
news • 23 Feb 2024
More consumers are realising meditation is beneficial, but many give up because it’s difficult to master the mind. The Muse ...
news • 21 Feb 2024
Newcomer to the market, Lunar Health Clubs, is gearing up to open its first high-end club this April, in Marlow ...
news • 19 Feb 2024
University of Washington researchers have created a wireless wearable in the form of a thermal earring that continuously monitors a ...
news • 16 Feb 2024
Zumba, and virtual reality workout platform, FitXR, have joined forces to offer mixed-reality versions of Zumba's dance routines. The partnership ...
news • 13 Feb 2024
Triathlon legends, Alistair and Jonny Brownlee, have launched a free conversational AI tool to share their vast training knowledge with ...
news • 07 Feb 2024
Self Esteem Brands (SEB), owner of Anytime Fitness, has released year-end results which show year-on-year revenues up by 12.3 per ...
More HCM news
According to McKinsey’s latest report, The trends defining the US$1.8 trillion global wellness market in 2024, the market for wellness ...
news • 24 Jan 2024
One of the most famous bodybuilders of all time – turned Hollywood actor – turned Californian governor – Arnold Schwarzenegger, ...
news • 23 Jan 2024
Egym has signalled its intention to become a major global player in the health club equipment space, signing up former ...
news • 19 Jan 2024
With pressure on medical services at an all time high, the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change is calling for ...
news • 17 Jan 2024
Sennheiser has teamed up with Polar Electro for the launch of its Momentum Sport earbuds which deliver Polar’s bio-sensing capabilities ...
news • 09 Jan 2024
The fitness industry is gearing up to engage with the medical profession according to the results of the American College ...
news • 05 Jan 2024
TikTok, has launched into the fitness market with a new hub called #TikTokFitness and a supporting consumer marketing push. The ...
news • 05 Jan 2024
Les Mills has released Les Mills XR Dance for the Meta Quest 3 headset. The release is the company's second ...
news • 20 Dec 2023
Equinox has appointed a Health Advisory Board of medical experts and academics to 'define new frontiers in the science of ...
news • 15 Dec 2023
Horizon Leisure is upgrading and investing in its new shopping-centre health hub – The Wellbeing Hub in Havant, UK – ...
news • 15 Dec 2023
Google has just released Gemini, a new multimodal AI which is being billed as a "ChatGPT Killer". Unlike ChatGPT, it ...
news • 06 Dec 2023
Survivalist, Bear Grylls has partnered with four mental health heavyweights and former TV producer, Neil Smith, to create an app ...
news • 06 Dec 2023
Sport Alliance has named Erwin Korst vice president sales international. The appointment comes as the company announces US$100m of new ...
news • 04 Dec 2023
Training provider, The Fitness Group, has teamed up with personal training app, My PT Hub, to make it easier for ...
news • 19 Nov 2023
The Maybourne Hotel Group – manager of iconic global hotels including Claridges, The Berkeley and The Connaught – has partnered ...
news • 17 Nov 2023
Timbaland, Platinum Grammy Award-winning producer, who's worked with artists such as Jay-Z, Missy Elliott, Madonna, Rihanna, Justin Timberlake and Drake ...
news • 15 Nov 2023
Connected fitness equipment supplier, Echelon Fitness, has signed a multi-year deal with Run Disney, the road race division of Disney ...
news • 14 Nov 2023
The first ever Siro hotel, marketed as the "ultimate fitness and recovery hotel", is now accepting reservations. Set to open ...
news • 09 Nov 2023
The rapid advance of technology in all areas of life is putting societies in flux, creating uncertainty and forcing people ...
news • 05 Nov 2023
Apple has teamed up with Anytime Fitness to offer levels of reciprocal access between Apple Fitness+ and Anytime Fitness health ...
news • 02 Nov 2023
Tech giant, Huawei, has launched a new Health Lab, where it will conduct research on how it can "provide better ...
news • 01 Nov 2023
Les Mills is jumping into Mixed Reality with the launch of the Bodycombat XR workout, designed by programme directors, Rachael ...
news • 16 Oct 2023
A new startup is looking to carve out a market for itself by helping those working in sports and physical ...
news • 12 Oct 2023
Interactive Strength, maker of fitness screen FORME, has revealed plans to acquire vertical climber brand CLMBR for an undisclosed sum. ...
news • 12 Oct 2023
More fit tech news